Amending Clay Garden Soil

The foundation of successful gardening is good soil. I always tell beginning gardeners that if they get the soil right they are two-thirds of the way to a beautiful garden. Unfortunately, few of us move into a home where the soil is already perfect. When I began digging my garden I was faced with a thick layer of highway grade gravel that was left over from when the then vacant lot was used as a community park. In order to remove all the gravel it was necessary to take with it most of the arable topsoil. That left me with a heavy, clay-based subsoil that was harder than a terra cotta pot.

Few things can strike fear into the hearts of gardeners like heavy clay soil. It is almost impossible to grow anything in the stuff. It is gooey when it is wet, and brick hard in the summer.

Why is Clay Soil So Troublesome?

The problem is that clay particles are very small in comparison to others found in the soil. For instance, if a clay particle were the size of a baseball, the average grain of sand would be, relatively speaking, the size of a Greyhound bus. Because clay particles are so tiny they pack together easily and become very dense, virtually impermeable to water and air, which are essential for healthy soil.

getting soil ready to garden

Use Humus to Improve Clay Soil

Now if you have clay soil, there is no reason to call in a backhoe or a D-9 dozer to dig it out. A better idea is to simply amend it. This will help break up the clay particles so water can trickle through and delicate roots can grow in the air pockets. The best way to separate these particles is to integrate coarser or larger particles such as humus. Humus is any decayed organic material like leaf mold, old ground up pine bark or compost. If you do not have a compost bin you can purchase bagged soil conditioner or even have it delivered by the cubic yard.

Get to Digging

Begin by loosening the clay in the area where you want to create a bed. Dig down about 12 inches. Once the ground is broken up add 3 inches of bagged garden soil, 3 inches of compost and 3 inches of ground, decomposed pine bark.

At the Garden Home we used Pro-Mix as our bagged soil amendment. It contains a biological growth enhancer called Mycorise®, which is a naturally occurring fungus that helps plant roots take in water and nutrients. The plant in turn provides carbohydrates for the fungi. Gardeners benefit from this symbiotic relationship by enjoying the vigorous plant growth it produces. If you push back the top layer of soil in your flower beds and see those white stripes then you've hit pay-dirt.

Once you have added all the amendments, till the ground until everything is well-blended. If you do not have access to a tiller you can do this by hand with a garden fork or shovel. It just takes more effort.

You will know that you have the texture right if you can squeeze a moist handful of soil in your fist and it easily falls apart when you open your hand.

Add Manure to Your Soil

Now to further improve your soil, add some well rotted manure. Not only does it help the composition of the soil but it brings nutrients as well. When you purchase a bag of basic commercial fertilizer like 13-13-13 you get 13% nitrogen, 13% phosphorous and 13% potassium but nothing else.

Granted these are staples that plants need, but they also need other trace elements such iron, boron, and magnesium. Manure has all these trace elements plus a heaping dose of nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium. For plants, manure is like a well-balanced meal and a multi-vitamin all in one.

I recommend purchasing manure in bags from your local garden center. Typically bagged manure has gone through a heat process that sterilizes any weed seeds that might be lurking in there and it helps to deodorize it. Also, you do not have to worry about it being too fresh and burning your plants. Check the back of the bag for recommend rates of application.

Once you have the texture just right and have added the manure, top the soil with 2 to 3 inches of wood mulch. I prefer pine bark chips, but any wood mulch will do. As the wood decomposes it will supply your garden with plenty of organic matter plus reduce weeds and retain moisture.

Good to Know:

Sandy soils can be amended too. Simply till in 2 to 3 inches of humus such as manure or compost to help bind the soil. This will improve water retention as well as add nutrients.

Share this articlePrint this article
Related articlesSave this article in your favorites

Comments

compost, humas, mulch

by Linda Hicks on April 26, 2010 05:51
What's the difference between compost, humas and mulch or are they all the same. Do you use them the same way? I'm looking to make my [clay & ground granite] dirt healthier and also keep the weeds down. Can I buy bulk of one and use for all reasons?

pine bark chips

by roy king on April 11, 2010 02:21
Is it true that pine bark. Is not good for tomato plants?

amending soil in an established garden

by Jackie Leib on March 30, 2010 08:42
I was wondering, in the spring, how do you amend the soil of an established garden? The garden was planted in the fall in a hurry and I want the best possible growing soil. Thank you.

Amending Clay Soil

by Joyce Rickman on March 28, 2010 08:37
We have clay soil which has been amended, we haven't added manure. Is it safe to plant veggies in?

Amending Clay Garden Soil

by Mark Briehl on March 27, 2010 08:22
A gardener friend suggested this fix for an established azalea bed that was slow draining with soggy soil. Remove the mulch, add 2-3 inches of compost to the bed, and re-mulch. Earthworms will work the compost in. Noticeable plant vigor within a couple months as the drainage improved. I do this annually now.

Clay Soils

by Arboretum at South Seattle Community College on March 26, 2010 08:18
Remember folks, you cannot change the nature of your bad soil's permanently. You must continue to amend the soil each season. Become of fan on facebook of the Arboretum at South Seattle Community College.

clay soil amending

by james evans on March 25, 2010 10:03
hope this works well i built an area using clay two feet to make a burm next to a drive, I topped it with 6" of top soil, will add more inputs this year, at least now,I know it's possible thanks as always. shellsburg. Iowa.

Re: Amending Clay Garden Soil

by Joy Anne Hendricksen on March 24, 2010 10:27
I hear your pain. I currently am working on a design for a property that used to be marsh. Some years past, when the house was built the contractor dumped five feet of fill and black dirt on top of the marsh, grading it to a slight slope to the road. The current home owner's well water and to some degree the soil has an oder and stains everything a rusty color. As a member of Wild Ones of Central WI, when the group met during the winter I asked their thoughts on this project, members include university Biologists and some DNR guys. They advised the issue was a lack of oxygen in the soil and water causing anarobic bacteria to form. The solution, I am told is the same as for compacted soil. Digging ditches running away from the house, filling the ditches with gravel in the bottom and then compost and live soil. We will see.

amending soil

by Ilse Burch on March 22, 2010 06:27
I would not have removed the gravel. I find gravel is lovely for growing lots of plants. Here where I live now we all have very gravelly soil. I actually import gravel for growing rock garden plants, and if I want to grow perennials I dig in lots of humus. You forgot to mention gypsum as a conditioner of clay soils. It helps clay soils become better-structured and is perfectly acceptable for organic gardening. I gardened on clay for the first 25 years of my gardening life. There are a lot of amendments that have better trace elements than manure- seaweed is a very good one. Mushroom compost is also much better than straight manure for amending clay soil because usually it contains gypsum and some other things that increase the trace elements.

amending soil

by Mike Cummins on March 22, 2010 06:16
We really enjoyed this article and the tips for amending clay soil. It came at a great time as we are moving garden plots, and the new area is high in clay content. My wife and I love your tv show and catch it on WILL- out of Champaign, Illinois. It is the fastest 30 minutes of the day!! Seems like the show just gets started, and it is over!!! Not many shows are as informative and enjoyable as yours!!! Keep up the GREAT work!!! Best Wishes....mc

Soil Amending

by David Hillgenberg on March 22, 2010 06:15
Excellent steps to amend soil are excellent and easy to follow.

SOIL AMENDMENT

by JUDY WAND on March 22, 2010 04:54
HOW DO YOU AMEND CLAY SOIL THAT ALREADY HAS PERENIALS PLANTED & GROWING? IT'S THE ANNUALS THAT I TRY TO INCORPORATE THAT DON'T DO VERY WELL. THANK YOU. JUDY WAND

Amending soil

by Jean Eckert on March 22, 2010 09:30
Good directions and reasoning for this new gardener. Thanks.

Amending Soil

by Regina Hayes on March 22, 2010 07:39
How do you amend soil in an already established garden?

Amending Soil

by Dennis Barrington on March 21, 2010 09:09
It is always nice to get refresher tips on how to amend soil -- really gives the plants a great head start.

Tomatoes

by Judy Hardy on March 21, 2010 08:44
For the past two years our summer starts out with lovely tomato plants. However around the time the tomatoes start to get of any size we notice brown marks starting on some of the leaves. The leaves slowly curl up and die and by the end of the summer we have very few leaves left on our plants and the stalks are pretty much dried up too. We get a fairly decent crop of tomatoes but the plants look so sickly. We water regularly and our other crops don't seem affected by what's happening to the tomatoes. We plan on planting tomatoes again this spring but we would like to know if there is something we could do to prevent this from happening again. Is it somekind of blight and can we prevent it? Thanks for your time

weeds

by Mary Black on March 21, 2010 08:08
I have a great organic garden started, I am 72 years old and had rather be in the dirt than in the kitchen cooking. I had a compost and the dollar weed got into it, How do I get rid of it? I use leaves and soil out of my husbands worm beds, which he puts lots of cow manure and I get the bottom part of the bins each year. Thanks

Re: Subject

by Linda Wood on March 21, 2010 07:45
I have pine bark mulch in the plot that I am helping my 7 yr. old grandson start for a veg. garden. My question is: Do I have to remove that mulch to add the manure or can I work the manure in the ground with the old mulch? thanks so much

Home grown manure & compost

by Belinda on March 21, 2010 02:50
Living in south Georgia & really appreciate this article on soil amendment! Although we use "home grown" horse & chicken manure & compost, then test the soil after it has had a generous watering & sat a while, sounds like we're on the money! Thank you!

WEEDS

by Paula Ketterl on March 21, 2010 01:58
I am one to pull up weeds as I see them and it seems that the drought we had here in Texas emboldened the weeds to unmanageable by pulling them up. I've got dandelions, dollar weed (all over the place), crab grass and worst, it seems because you just can't pull it up) is Nut grass. What is a good all around poison for these weeds? I can dig & dig and never have energy or time to plant. Please help. By the way, I so enjoy your newsletter and the ideas and info. Thank you. Paula

Amending the soil

by Athena Dascalos on March 21, 2010 01:34
Thasnk for the helpful tips on amending the soil. I heard it is best to do this in the fall, but now seems like the right time too.

Ammending soil

by Christine Graham Smiley on March 21, 2010 12:12
I love reading your articles and visit Pallen Smiths wesite often. I have been working on my gardens for years. Thankfully I have horses and have three stages of manure that I put in my gardens every year. I had a problem with clay as well and putting manure deep into the ground has really helped the conition of my gardens. Last year I had killer tomatoes for a long time.

amending clay soil

by gaines hedges on March 21, 2010 10:16
In West Tennessee we too have clay soil. Most of the gardeners I know use a formula which probably came out of Memphis years ago. 1/3 gravel tailings or filter media, 1/3 peat moss and 1/3 soil. ...now you have a good top soil and the beds are so easy to work in and maintain.

Marl

by Marilyn on March 21, 2010 10:10
Could you give me your recommendations as to how to amend marl, please? Thanks

clay

by K Halcrow on March 21, 2010 08:33
We have so much clay and so little soil and the clay was so compacted, that despite numerous additions as recommended here I still wasn't having good enough results. I finally started digging extra deep beneath plants I was adding and and putting in a few inches of gravel then dirt then plant, then fill the hole. The problem was the scale issue I think -- didn't have the strength to dig up the entire brick like yard to properly amend it to the depth needed. My "solution" is working so far despite a week of tremendous rain. We had that type of rain a few years back before my solution and a lot of my plants died, which is how I came up with this.

soil amendment

by Nancy on March 21, 2010 08:08
This information is great but what do you do when you need to amend the soil and there are plants there? This is more than just add some nutrients from the top.

Amending Planted Soil

by Betsy Patterson on March 20, 2010 08:52
I understand the principles of amending soil when planting a new bed, but what is the best approach to improve clay soil that has already been planted in perennials and shrubs? Please don't say that it's necessary to pull everything out to till in amendments. What things can be added/top-dressed that will, in time, produce a loamy soil? I'm sure I'm not the only one who has inherited this problem, so others would like your advice, also. Thank you. Betsy

Clay Soils

by JT on March 20, 2010 04:57
I am surprised you did not recommend adding gypsum. It helps to break up the clay. I find it interesting that the Highway Department now uses it extensivley on clay subsoils.

Amending clay soil

by Louise on March 20, 2010 04:23
Dig down to 12 inches?? In compacted clay soil?? You have to be kidding. The rest of your suggestions are actually doable. But don't think this article helped those who hoped we could actually conquer clay.

container soil

by Carolyn on March 20, 2010 01:53
I have a terrace with pots and wood barrels and the soil is fairly compact. I also have perenniels that have almost no soil but plenty of roots. How do I re-nourish the soil? Thanks.

amending soil

by Helen on March 20, 2010 10:49
How can I get rid of the moss in my flower beds without hurting the plants. These are perennial beds and cannot rework the soil very well. These beds are not in the shade or overly wet so don'y know what is causing so much moss. Thank you

Re: Amending Clay Garden Soil

by BORIS on March 20, 2010 10:03
VERY MANY MANY THANKS FOR YOUR GREAT TIP!!!!!!!!

elephant dung

by OliviaE on March 20, 2010 05:53
PAllen, I have been offered elephant dung for my garden. I was planning on tilling it in along with my compost pile for my garden this year. Do you think I will need to add other nutrients and do you think that this would burn my garden?

Amending Clay Soil

by Gardening 4 Life on March 19, 2010 09:46
Something we've learned in Texas about amending clay soil is to use "expanded shale". This is recommended through A&M's Master Gardener program. We have blackland clay soil here and the expanded shale really helps to aerate and break up the clay rather than make concrete-like soil. Once its been added, you don't have to replace it like other amendments.

Amending garden soil

by Carol Shaw on February 3, 2010 11:31
What kind of sand should be added and where can you purchase it? I read about this once and added play sand to a potted hibiscus and it turned to stone! Thanks! Carol Shaw

Raised Bed Soil Mixture

by Pam on February 18, 2009 01:09
Hi, Mr P. Allen Smith: For a raised vegetable bed I am considering using 1/3 peat moss, 1/3 vermiculite, & 1/3 compost. This idea is from a book: Square Foot Gardening. The book goes on to say that only 6 inch depth is required. I have looked into your mixture and curious which do you think I would have the most nutritious vegetables. Also on my property I have cleared an acre of land of mature pine trees and wondering if the soil is considered Compost?or Topsoil? My soil test results are: PH-low, PHOSPHORUS-very low, POTASSIUM-low, CALCIUM-very low, MAGNESIUM - high, SODIUM - optimum, SULFUR-high, COPPER- high, ZINC - low. Any help would be appreciated. Thank you.pam

sandy soil

by Helen Cowan on February 9, 2009 09:27
I live in South Ga. and the area that I would like to put a vegetable garden is sandy soil. What do I need to do to make this area appropriate for vegetables?

plants turning yellow

by mike warren on November 24, 2008 11:25
some of my plants are turning yellow. what might be the problem? soil,to much sun, to much shsde.

Azaleas

by Johnetta on November 7, 2008 06:06
I didn't do a good job of planting my azaleas 2 years ago as they have not grown or produced blooms. Do I have to dig them you and amend the soil or just add nutrients around them?

Garden manure

by Susan Wolfe on October 16, 2008 11:22
Have you ver tried rabbit manure in your garden? It's really good as you don't have to wait for it to cure, and it won't burn plants. I grew up on a rabbit farm in Ohio. I live in Tennessee presently. Wish I had some of that great Ohio soil. Loved your article. Thanx! PS I was researching "burning garden debris right in the garden, as you go" when I came across your article. We had a bad experience with squash bugs this year. I thought maybe we could burn them out. We also have a lot of tree limbs to burn. Thought maybe we could burn them right in the garden. What do you think, would that work or be a bad idea? Again thank you folks!

Amending garden soil

by Lynn on October 14, 2008 03:58
Thank you Allen this is just the information I need right now. The last four days I've been digging up my raised beds that had been overtaken with bermuda grass. Here in the southwest deserst bermuda can become a real pest in the garden. Our planting schedules are so different in the sonoran desert as compared to the rest of the nation. September is our time to plant vegetable and flower seeds for a winter and spring crop. Besides ridding my garden of bermuda and its invasive roots, I want my soil good and rich for fall planting. Thank you again for this article. I'm now off to get the right ingredients for a well amended garden.

Question about safety of soil additive

by Jennifer on September 27, 2008 09:34
Is it safe or good to add ashes to our garden soil from our burn pile ? We burn tree branches and all other garden debris in our town. I want to know if it's ok to add to our soil.

Re: Amending Garden Soil

by james on September 8, 2008 09:09
I would go very easy on the wood mulch, it's a sure fire way for the nitrogen to be absorbed away from the plants... i almost can't belive it is suggested for use here. Non composted leaf mulch added with finished compost would be much safer.

soil

by cheryl williams on September 6, 2008 02:59
thank you for your help here, now we will see what next year brings us. I have a very small area for my garden. Probable 12ftx50ft. I have been growing tomatoe which do pretty good, but seem to have a hard time with other things. Broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, onions, things like that. I live in eastern washington, so it is pretty hot in summer times. I am hoping to get a good soil mixture here and see what happens

cotton seed

by evelyn on July 28, 2008 10:05
I saw you on our early morning news show you were giving a cotton seed mixture with magnesium and other stuff I would like to know that mixture and how much of each. P.S. I watch the early morning news between 5:30 - 6 am just to catch your comments.

Compost Tea

by GWEN SLAUGHTER on July 8, 2008 07:12
THE ABOVE ARTICLE HELPED ME A LOT, BUT I AM LOOKING FOR A HOW TO ON COMPOST TEA. I HEARD IT ON ONE OF YOUR PROGRAMS, THE STATEMENT WAS USED BY A GUEST, BUT I NEVER HOW IS THE TEA MADE. I'M JUST GETTING INTO GROWING A SMALL GARDEN. GOT ANY IDEAS ON HOW TO MAKE THIS TEA. THANKS, Gwen

Established Garden Problem

by Cecilia on June 27, 2008 10:41
I hope you can help I usually have a fairly good luck with my gardens perennials & annuals alike. However this year I fine myself scratching my head & getting more frustrated by the day. Last year I re-fertilized all the beds, with a good seasoned compost & manure mixture form my local garden center & all beds looked very good. This year they look awful! The annuals that I planted 5 weeks ago look no bigger then the day I put them in, even leaves are yellowing! The established perennials are doing well. The new perennials are not so good I even have one Blanket Flower that is dying a stalk at a time, when the one dyes off I cut it off & in a few days the next starts to wilt & dries up. The first 2 weeks all new plants get watered everyday, as I always have unless it rains that day. We have had above average rain fall in the area, I am going out this weekend I guess & buy a fertilizer in the hopes that will help… Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Celia

Re: Amending Garden Soil

by on June 23, 2008 10:37
I tried llama "beans" one year. I stirred them in real good, but digging in the dirt two years later, I came across full beans so I don't think they are such a good idea. You will want to amend the soil for the initial planting, and everytime you dig or replant or move something, you will want to add more good stuff to the soil. Many plants like a handful of mulch mixed in the planting hole. I've had terrific success with my hosta doing this. kt

Soil Conditioners

by Rudy De Martelaere on May 31, 2008 04:14
The cheapskate builder of our development didn't spend much money on top soil in the flower beds around the house. You dig 3 or 4 inches into the soil and you hit sand, that is if you don't hit chunks of concrete. It requires a lot of effort when getiing toe soil ready for planting even simple things like flowers. Bushes is even worse.

Mulch

by Rudy De Martelaere on May 31, 2008 04:06
On one of your shows I was watching one Saturday morning, you suggested some type of mulch in lieu of wood chips. What exactly was that mulch?

Garden Soil

by Mary Picklesimer on May 11, 2008 07:36
Our garden area was full of gravel and clay. I sifted the soil with a small screen that my husband made me. It took time but it worked. I put the dirt in buckets and when I was down to 18", I put scredded paper in the hole and replaced the dirt. The worms and night crawlers did the rest. I also save my egg shells to give the birds a treat and slugs don't like the sharp edges. Mixing Miracle Grow Potting Soil to the sifted dirt also adds volumn and nutrients. This method takes patience and time but is a sure thing without spending hugh amounts of money.

Deer Lovely Deer

by Dick Crook on May 10, 2008 07:59
Please recomendations for a deer deterrent without putting up a 5' 'fence? They also destroyed my arborvitae hedge and my yews. Do you think my lovely wife feeding them has anything to do with it?

Deer Lovely Deer

by Dick Crook on May 10, 2008 07:48
I have a real problem with deer in my garden as many of you probably do. What is the best deterrent without putting up a fence?

fine tree roots in soil

by Michele Bugyi on April 20, 2008 08:04
We have a problem with fine hair tree roots growing in our flower beds. We have removed the soil and roots and added new soil, but the roots still grow in the beds choking out our plants. Any suggestions?

Amending Garden Soil

by Ed Muckey on April 10, 2008 02:38
Mr. Smith, I agree with all you have said on this subject, but, I would add one more ingrediant or step to the process. I would suggest that earth worms be added to the final ammended soil. They not only aid in decomposion of the additional organic matter but also add great nutriants to the soil. Additionally they will, given time, attack the surrounding clay soil and break it down. These garden worms are the un-sung hero's of soil ammendants.

alpaca manure

by Lynn on February 29, 2008 01:37
I've been told that alpaca manure can be applied directly to the garden plot with composting it first. Please advise--I always soak my vegetables in a 5% bleach solution and rinse before I eat/store them.

Help with manure?

by Mary on February 27, 2008 06:35
After reading your suggestions on amending the soil I was wondering if you could give us a foolproof formula for preparing horse manure to use in our beds. I have horses, as do almost all of my friends, so we have a ready "supply" of raw material.

amending the soil

by paula watson on February 21, 2008 09:49
hi! i want to know if i don't use manure what else can i use to amend my soil, will compost and a orgainic fertilizer be ok?

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.