Why Login?Logging in will give you access to features such as:
  • Saving Favorites
  • Entering Contests
  • Adding Plants
  • Adding Photos

Register for a free account!

* - Indicates required fields User name:* First name: Last name: Email address:* Password:* Confirm password:* Country: Region: State: Zip: Keep in touch with P. Allen Smith's weekly e-newsletter. Yes! I would like to receive the email newsletter. No thanks! If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code. Please type code from above:*

Cilantro, Culantro, Papalo

One of the great characteristics of herbs is that they are so easy to grow. But there is one herb that I have a difficult time with and that's Coriandrum sativum. You may know it by the common names coriander or cilantro. If the plant is grown for the seeds it is called coriander; the leaves are referred to as cilantro. Perhaps it is the multiple names that makes this herb so complicated.

Unfortunately cilantro has me in a difficult spot because I love the flavor so much. I like to have plenty on hand to brighten soups, salads and salsas.

When it comes to growing cilantro I have 2 issues. For one thing it has an extremely short life span. When purchased as a plant at the nursery it often peters out within a few weeks.

Another problem I have is humidity and heat. Cilantro prefers a cool, dry climate, conditions that are sadly lacking in my mid-south garden during summer. Similar to lettuce, cilantro will bolt and become bitter as soon as temperatures begin to rise.

I have better luck growing cilantro during the extended mild weather typical of fall in my region. So just before the heat breaks in late summer I sow seeds for autumn harvest.

There are a few tips to keep in mind when growing cilantro from seed. First, the seedlings don't transplant well so it is best to direct sow them in the garden or a generous sized container. Pick a location that is in full sun with well-drained soil.

Cilantro seedlings also resent being crowded so thin them to 3 to 4 inches apart.

And finally consistent moisture is a must as the seedlings emerge.

I find that if I sow a crop at the end of August and then again 2 weeks later I have plenty of this flavorful herb to last me until the first hard freeze.


Papalo

This year I decided to expand my repertoire and try some of the alternatives to cilantro. I'm growing papalo (Porophyllum ruderale) and culantro (Eryngium foetidum). Both have a similar flavor to cilantro, but are better suited to my garden's climate.

Papalo is a native plant from South and Central America. I sowed a few seeds directly in the vegetable garden in early summer and they have grown quite well. Tall and spindly, the plant is not especially attractive. However the leaves are a nice gray-green and a nearby Malabar spinach vine does a pretty good job filling in the gaps. I also like the flavor; it has a hint of lime in addition to the cilantro flavor.


Culantro

Culantro is a cousin of the perennial sea holly - a plant I love for its metallic blue, spiky blooms. Culantro is native to South East Asia, Central America and Florida and it loves heat and humidity. It will thrive in shade to partial shade and moist soil. I sowed the seed in a container in spring and it is now about 6 to 8 inches tall. The foliage has the serrated edges typical of the eryngium family.

Neither papalo and culantro do well cooked so they should either be eaten raw or added to recipes are the very last minute.

Write a comment

  • Required fields are marked with *.

If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code.
 
Showing comments 1 to 10 of 17 | Next | Last
Comment
recao
Robert Beatie
Reply #17 on : Mon August 31, 2009, 17:21:25
I like to cook Puerto Rican dishes using recao for my Puerto Rican wife, but I can never find it in stores. It would probably be next to impossible to grow it here in the Coachella Valley. It is 109 today and it was 119 yesterday. Is there somewhere that I can order the stuff?
Comment
culantro seeds avail. free
Virginia Wayne
Reply #16 on : Tue June 30, 2009, 17:46:27
write me a note and I will be happy to send you some seed.
Comment
Culantro
Norma
Reply #15 on : Wed June 03, 2009, 15:22:01
Where can I find culantro seeds??? I live in Florida and have been looking at walmart, etc. and cannot find?????
Comment
Re: Cilantro, Culantro, Papalo
Norma
Reply #14 on : Wed June 03, 2009, 15:20:15
Culantro is also native in Puerto Rico and is base for the "sofrito" which we use to cook from beans to yellow rice,etc. It is also known as "recao". For us it does very well cooked.
Comment
Culantro
Dania
Reply #13 on : Wed April 29, 2009, 18:50:22
Just for your information culantro (also Recao) is used as part of the base cooking in the caribbean (Sofrito) also is added to soup or chicken broth.
Comment
Papalo Seed Source
michaelC
Reply #12 on : Tue April 21, 2009, 03:37:45
Nichols Garden Nursery's 2009 catalog (www.nicholsgardennursery.com) has Papaloquelite, another name for papalo. Nichols is located in Oregon.
Comment
What is eating my cilantro
Kris
Reply #11 on : Sun April 19, 2009, 11:03:01
I just planted cilanto yesterday and this morning I looked at it, and it looks like someone used a pairs of sizzors and cut it all off right above the surface of the soil. And then I remembered that a few years ago I had the same probelm with cilantro (which I haven't grown since). All my other herbs and vegetable plants have gone un-touched. Any ideas what it might be and what I can do to stop it??? I live in North Georgia.
Comment
papalo seed
PAllen
Reply #10 on : Mon March 09, 2009, 17:36:08
Angeles - if you read the post immediately below yours it lists a website where you can contact Jim Long to get some seeds. His web address is listed below. Regards, P. Allen Smith
Comment
papalo
Angeles Lozano
Reply #9 on : Fri March 06, 2009, 18:25:57
Where can I find papalo seeds? I've tried ordering from several catalogs and they all say it's not available. Love to try it this summer. Thanks.
Comment
Papalo
Jim Long
Reply #8 on : Mon October 27, 2008, 13:55:50
I have papalo seed if anyone would like some. Mine came from a friend in Bolivia and I've been growing it for about 4 years. The flavor isn't quite the same as cilantro, but when picked very young and tender, has that flavor with a hint of lemon. (Older plants earn the common name, "buzzard's breath.")
I have a photo of the plant on my blog http://jimlongsgarden.blogspot.com/ and I'm happy to share seed.
Jim Long Longcreekherbs@yahoo.com
Showing comments 1 to 10 of 17 | Next | Last

Rate It!

3/5 stars (803 votes)


Share It!

Bookmark and Share
Add To Favorites
Why Login?Logging in will give you access to features such as:
  • Saving Favorites
  • Entering Contests
  • Adding Plants
  • Adding Photos

Sign Up For Newsletter